Ice Cream Cakes
Papa Jim's now makes Ice Cream Cakes
Ready To Go Cakes
Ready-to-Go Ice Cream Cakes at Lake Monticello
Looking for something sweet and stress-free? Our Lake Monticello shop has freshly made ice cream cakes ready when you are.
​
-
Small (8" round, 3" high): Serves 6–8
-
Large (10" round, 3" high): Serves 12–16
-
​
Every cake is layered with rich Chocolate Soft Serve and creamy Vanilla Soft Serve, with a ribbon of decadent Fudge in between.
PJIC Signature Cakes
Papa Jim’s Signature Cakes are here to satisfy every craving! From our rich Whole Lotta Chocolate to classics like Oreo, Strawberry Chocolate, Birthday Cake, Nutella, and so many more.
[Click here to explore the full lineup!]
Please remember: Signature Cakes require 48 hours to prepare, so be sure to order ahead!
Custom Cakes
Have a special ice cream cake combination in mind? We’ve got you covered!
Mix and match any two layers of ice cream with your choice of icing and colored piping, and we’ll create the perfect cake just for you.
Click here to view all our options and fill out the Cake Order Form.
Please remember: Custom Cakes require 48 hours to prepare, so be sure to order ahead!